Saturday 22 February 2020

Column | Window Seat 23.2.20


Window Seat | Mrinal Chatterjee | 23.2.20

Mooknayak at 100

Mooknayak (The Leader of the Voiceless) was a Marathi fortnightly newspaper Babasaheb Ambedkar started in 1920. He was 29 then. It was his first journalistic venture. Its first issue was published on 31 January 2020. Ambedkar’s aim in launching this journal was to put forward his own point of view on matters such as the evils of untouchability, the socio-economic status of ‘untouchables’, their status in the Hindu society, would swaraj bring about any change in their status, etc. These issues and questions had hitherto not found due representation in mainstream Hindi journals. Ambedkar tried to bring forth these issues to the limelight.


The tone was set from the very first editorial that he wrote in the opening issue:
“The Hindu society is like a tower of many stories. It has neither a ladder nor a door to go out. And therefore there is no way to interchange stories. Those who are born on a particular storey die in that storey. Even if the lowest storey person is worthy deserving to be promoted to the upper storey he cannot move to that level. And if the person in the upper storey is most unworthy and undeserving still he cannot be pushed down” …….
Though he was officially not associated with it (as he was in government service then), it was Babasaheb’s paper. In fact he wrote many of the editorials that were published in this paper. However, Shri Nandra Bhatkar was the first editor of the paper. Later Shri Dyander Gholap was the editor.
Mooknayak went through many ups and downs. It remained in circulation just for three years. Despite its short life, Mooknayak laid the foundations of an assertive and organised Dalit politics. It announced the arrival of a newer generation of anti-caste politics that broke the confines of region, language and political boundaries and coincided with the larger developments on the nationalist scene. 

Good news from Population front

A large and growing population has long being considered as one of the reason of India’s poverty. Leaders in India tried to engage with this issue quite early on. In fact India is the first country in Asia to adopt a family planning programme. It is the first developing country to do so in 1951. Since then, the country’s population has quadrupled with 1.37 billion people in 2019.
However, for the first time after independence- we have some real good news in population front. Darrell Bricker, Author of Empty Planet says,  India’s total fertility rate (TFR) has reached replacement level. Srinivas Goli, Asstt. Professor of Population Studies at the Centre for the Study of Regional Development, JNU says that the TFR in India will dip below the replacement level by 2021.
What is TFR? Population scientists have postulated a threshold to the number of births to keep the population under control. This is expressed as Total Fertility Rate (TFR), which is the average number of children a woman of childbearing age must have. Population above TFR means growth, while that below2 TFR means decline. At TFR, population is maintained. For Homo Sapiens a 2.1 TFR would keep the country’s population stable. The UN Population Division terms this as the replacement-level fertility.
India has either just reached that or is very close to that point now. The National Family Health Survey (NFHS 4) conducted in 2015-16, found India’s TFR has reached 2.2. Most Indian States had already achieved or were below 2.1 TFR. However, the major exceptions were Bihar (3.4), UP (2.7) Jharkhand (2.6), Rajasthan (2.4) and Madhya Pradesh (2.3). Except Jharkhand all other states are large and with large population. Once the TFR dips in these states- the national TFR will dip below 2.1 and that will be good for the country- for at least three four decades or so.
But if the TFR dips very low (as Darrell Bricker predicts would happen)- then, we’ll have to rethink and re-strategize. 

Capitalizing Corona Virus

Bhojpuri music industry is amazing. It can churn out songs on any issue for any occasion. Looking at the media space Corona Virus is occupying, there are at least two music CDs releasing on the occasion of Holi- on this.
Consider the titles: Lehenga me virus corona ghusal ba. Meaning: Corona Virus has entered in the Lehenga. This song is sung by ‘Diamond Star’ Guddu Rangila. The other CD has a simpler title: Corona Virus Kaisal ba? How is the Corona Virus. Singer: Jallu Raja.
Creativity- thy name is Bhojpuri Music.

Tailpiece: Corona Scare

Two friends met in a jam-packed local train, no place even to stand properly.
One of them said to the other, a bit loudly: 
"Are Bhai, glad to see you, but when did u return from China!?" 
That did the trick! 
In a few minutes the two were the only ones left in the compartment!!
(Courtesy: Social Media)
***
A journalist turned media academician the columnist lives in Central Odisha town of Dhenkanal. Compilation of his weekly column Window Seat, published in 2019 has been put together as an e-book. To get a free copy send an email to: mrinalchatterjeeiimc@gmail.com

Pathe Prantare 23.2.20

Samay Taranga 23.2.20

Saturday 15 February 2020

Window Seat 16.2.20


Window Seat | Mrinal Chatterjee | 16.2.20

Do media impact culture?

Recently I attended a conference on ‘Culture, Media and Development’ at Baba Saheb Ambedkar Open University, Ahmedabad. There was prolonged discussion on: whether media impacts culture or culture impacts media? If both do, then who impacts more? 
My take was: media, especially the all-pervasive tech-driven media have started impacting the culture like never before. Let me give you just three examples. Look at what has happened to the practice of reading newspaper in the morning. It used to be a family affair. Or for that matter television viewing. Look at what has happened to the practice of scouting for bride/groom. Look at the growing practice of online dating. There is a TV serial now showing a young girl encouraging his widowed father to go for online dating. Look at what has happened to the age old Bengali practice of writing 'Bijoya pranam' letters. Last Puja we received none. Zero. We got phone calls and whatsapp messages with digital rasagola or rasagolla- depending on where it came from - Odisha or Bengal.
Agreed- these are all outer non-core areas of our culture, which is comparatively easy to breach. But once the outer areas of our culture are punctured with ease- media can (or can be  used to) put sustained pressure on the core and eventually breach and change it.

Turbulent Days for Print Media

India’s fourth estate, particularly the print media is staring at imminent danger. Several newspapers across the country are gasping for breath. Shrinking readership and ad revenues, rising costs, waning credibility, and an onslaught of digital and social media have taken a huge toll on their financial health. Recently published data collected by the Indian Readership Survey shows that their future is pretty bleak.
Many media pundits believe that print media (newspaper or magazine) as stand-alone media product hardly has any future. Media houses must have multiple products in multiple delivery platforms to monetize and survive.

Mooknayak at 100

Mooknayak (The Leader of the Mute or The Leader of the Voiceless), the first journalistic venture of Babasaheb Ambedkar, was a weekly Marathi newspaper he started in 1920. Its first issue was published on 31 January 2020. His aim in launching this journal was to put forward his own point of view on matters such as Swaraj, the education of the ‘untouchables’, and the evils of untouchability, which had hitherto not found due representation in mainstream Hindi journals.

Though he was officially not associated with it (as he was in government service then), it was Babasaheb’s paper. In fact he wrote all the editorials that were published in this paper. However, Shri Nandra Bhatkar was the first editor of the paper. Later Shri Dyander Gholap was the editor.
Mooknayak went through many ups and downs. It remained in circulation just for three years. Despite its short life, Mooknayak laid the foundations of an assertive and organised Dalit politics. It announced the arrival of a newer generation of anti-caste politics that broke the confines of region, language and political boundaries and coincided with the larger developments on the nationalist scene. 

Fake and Real

We wash our hands with real lemon pieces and drink lemon flavored carbonated water- in effect fake lemon juice. Gradually we are in love with 'fake' and barely tolerate 'real'. It is gradually permeating into our culture, and this is becoming the only culture globally. Fake is becoming the new real.

Valentine Week special

Khud talashna katil apni aur phir katl ho jana
Isi phankari ko badkismati se isq kahate hain
(Finding one’s own executioner and then getting executed
This artistry, unfortunately, is known as love.
(Courtesy: Social Media)

Post Valentine Scenario: Love and Marraige

When you are in love,
Wonders happen.
But once you get married,
You wonder, what happened
***
A journalist turned media academician the columnist lives in Central Odisha town of Dhenkanal. mrinalchatterjeeiimc@gmail.com
This column is published every Sunday in Sikkim Express

Window Seat 9.2.20


Window Seat | Mrinal Chatterjee 9.2.20

CULTURE: WHY WE SHOULD SIMULTANEOUSLY PRESERVE IT 

AND ALLOW CHANGES?

            In the context of humanities and sociology culture means the ideas, customs, and social behavior of a particular people or society. Culture is considered a central concept in anthropology, encompassing the range of phenomena that are transmitted through social learning in human societies. Culture is a word for the ‘way of life’ of groups of people, meaning the way they do things. Different groups may have different cultures.  A culture is passed on to the next generation by learning, whereas genetics are passed on by heredity.

            Cultures are what make countries unique. Each country may have different cultural activities and cultural rituals. Culture includes material goods, the things the people use and produce. Also the beliefs and values of the people and the ways they think about and understand the world and their own lives.

            Culture can also vary within a region, society or sub group. A region of a country may have a different culture that they rest of the country. For example, in a large country like India or China a region may have a distinctive language, different types of music, and different types of music, and different types of dances.

            It is important to preserve culture of a society, State or country because that is part of its identity. Every culture that disappears diminishes a possibility of life. Keeping culture intact equals to patriotism, self-respect, the values of a nation, rich history as well as a great way forward.

            Culture preservation includes documenting and studying languages: preserving and restoring historic relics significant to a culture or heritage; and encouraging the preservation and use of indigenous or tribal languages and rituals.
           
            Culture is pervasive. It touches every aspect of life. The pervasiveness of culture is manifest in two ways. First, culture provides an unquestioned context within which individual action and response take place. Not only emotional action but relational actions are governed by cultural norms. Second, culture pervades social activities and institutions.

            Culture is not a force, operating by itself and independent of the human actors. There is an unconscious tendency to defy culture, to endow it with life and treat it as a thing. Culture is a creation of society in interaction and depends for its existence upon the continuance of society.

            In a strict sense, therefore, culture does not ‘do’ anything on its own. It does not cause the individual to act in a particular way, nor does it ‘make’ the normal individual into a  maladjusted one. Culture, in short, is a human product; it is not independently endowed with life.

            However, we must remember that there is one fundamental and in escapable attribute of culture: the fact of unending change. Some societies at sometimes change slowly, and hence in comparison to other societies seem not to be changing at all. But they are changing, even though not obviously so. Culture in not static. It changes with time and change in technology.

            It is like a flowing river. The river rarely changes its course-it more or less remains the same, but the water continues to flow. It is never static. If it does not flow than the river ultimately die. This analogy is true for any culture. l It needs to be practiced and changed with time to make it relevant and practice worthy.

            Cultures undergo a gradual change. With passing time, some beliefs change, certain traditions or rituals are eliminated, language and  mannerisms of people  change and thus their culture. Migration and globalization lead to a mixing of cultures. When people from different parts of the world come together, they influence each other and effectively, each other’s cultures. These factors contribute to the formation of a multicultural society and sometimes, even new cultures develop.

            Due  to education and increased awareness, newer generations become flexible to change and look at concepts like religion and culture with a broader perspective and have a liber4al view about them,. So some rituals or customs become less rigid, some are replaced by simpler ones and some are discontinued.

            Due to the exposure to various cultures across the globe, people adopt some aspects of other cultures. This affects what they teach their children, thus influencing the culture of their future generations and in a small way, leading to a cultural change.  Social thinking undergoes a transition and so does culture. Gender roles change. For instance, traditionally, the males were meant to work and earn for their family, while women stayed at home and looked after the children.  Today these roles have changed. In many families, women work away from home, while men take care of the kids.

            All cultures change in time although their rate of change varies. It’s often seen that the politically or economically stronger countries influence cultures in other parts of the world and lead to social changes in the concerned countries.

            Thus, there is a need to preserve culture. But one should not be puritan and averse to change. On the other hand too sudden or too pervasive a change would kill a culture. We must balance this two opposing things carefully.

Tailpiece: Corona

Don’t be so afraid of the corona virus. It won’t last long. After all it is made in China.
But of course you need to take precaution. However, Bengalis and to some extent Odias need not worry. They have been taking precaution against corona from childhood:
Eta corona
Ota corona
Birokto corona
Bandrami (mankadami in Odia) corona
Maramari corona
Nachanachi corona, etc.

Tailpiece 2: Accountancy Fact

What is the difference between Liability and Asset?
A drunk friend is liability. But, A drunk Girlfriend is an Asset
(Courtesy: Social Media)

***
An anthology of his weekly column Window Seat, published in 2019 is being published as a book. Should you want a copy with introductory discounted price, write to him at: mrinalchatterjee@ymail.com
This column is published every Sunday in Sikkim Express.



Pathe Prantare 16.2.20

Samaya Taranga 16.2.20

Wednesday 5 February 2020

Window Seat 2.2.20


Window Seat | Mrinal Chatterjee | 2.2.20

200 years of Vidyasagar

This year, the Nation is celebrating the 200 years of the birth of Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar.  (26 September 1820 – 29 July 1891). Born Ishwar Chandra Bandyopadhyay. he received the title "Vidyasagar" (in Sanskrit Vidya means knowledge and Sagar means ocean, i.e., Ocean of Knowledge) from Sanskrit College, Calcutta (from where he graduated), due to his excellent performance in Sanskrit studies and philosophy.

Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar was a philosopher, academic educator, writer, translator, printer, publisher, entrepreneur, reformer and philanthropist. He was at the forefront of Bengali Renaissance along with social reformer Ram Mohan Roy. He helped shape modern Bengali, and in an extension, the Indian society.
He was the most prominent campaigner for Hindu widow remarriage and petitioned Legislative council despite severe opposition. It was his campaign and Lord Dalhousie’s initiative that led to Hindu Widows' Remarriage Act, 1856.
Vidyasagar’s efforts to simplify and modernize Bengali prose were significant. He also rationalised and simplified the Bengali alphabet and type.
Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar opened several schools for women and was instrumental in bringing the Hindu Widows' Remarriage Act in 1856.
He also modified the rules of getting admission in Sanskrit college to allow non-Brahmin students there.
He was one of the first persons to have realized the potential of newspaper as a toolfor social reform. He was associated with several newspapers including Somprakash (Bengali) and Hindoo Patriot (English).
Vidyasagar did not get his due recognition during his lifetime. In fact he faced severe social opposition. His personal life- towards the end was tragic. But he stood steadfast in his mission to reform the society.

Existential Crisis

An existential crisis may occur when a person frequently wonders whether or not life has any inherent meaning or purpose. A person may also question their own existence within a world that might seem meaningless.

Experiencing an existential crisis is common, and it is normal and often healthy to question one’s life and goals. However, an existential crisis can contribute to a negative outlook, especially if a person cannot find a solution to their questions of meaning.

Existential crises may be associated with a number of mental health conditions. For this reason, it is sometimes best to involve a doctor — especially if an existential crisis has the potential to lead to despair or suicidal ideation.

Haiku on KONARK


A haiku is an unrhymed Japanese poetic form that consists of 17 syllables arranged in three lines containing five, seven, and five syllables, respectively. A haiku expresses much and suggests more in the fewest possible words. The form gained distinction in the 17th century, when Basho, a Japanese poet considered the greatest practitioner of the form, elevated it to a highly refined art. It remains Japan’s most popular poetic form. The Imagist poets (1912–30) and others have imitated the form in English and other languages.
Jaipur, Rajasthan based Himanshu Vyas, a National Award winner photojournalist indulges in various art forms including haiku. Here are some of his haiku on Konark Sun Temple, a thirteen century marvel built on Bay of Bengal coast about 30 kms from Puri.
1.      sea breeze
sweaty smell from
warm sculptures

2.      spitting betel juice
guide withholds
secrets of carved queen

3.      statue of dancer;
tourist’s wrist slowly rests
on waist

4.      in stone spokes
a green sprout keeps
the ‘wheel’ moving
5.      carved danseuse
anklets
of hasty pilgrim

Tailpiece 1: Economics

Economics is not that difficult if we have the right examples.
Interviewer: What is Recession? 
Candidate: When "Wine & Women" get replaced by "Water & Wife", that critical phase of life is called Recession!!

Tailpiece 2: Difference

If you think you are too small to make a difference......try sleeping with a mosquito in the room! 
***
The author, a journalist turned media academician lives in Central Odisha town of Dhenkanal.
An anthology of his weekly column Window Seat, published in 2019 is being published as a book. Should you want a copy with introductory discounted price, write to him at: mrinalchatterjee@ymail.com