Saturday, 4 November 2017

Column | Window Seat

Window Seat | Mrinal Chatterjee
Agriculture in India
There is a saying in Sanskrit: Banijye basati Laxmi, tatardhen krishi karmane. Translated in English it would be: Laxmi resides in business; farming yields half of that. But the condition of most of the farmers in India seems to be much worse than this. Hundreds of them are committing suicide in Maharastra, Andhra Pradesh, Odisha and many other states. Odisha is facing a grim situation now as farmers in Western Odisha are burning their paddy fields fearing total loss of crop as pests ravage their standing paddy.   
This is ironical considering the fact that the history of Agriculture in India dates back to Indus Valley Civilization Era and even before that in some parts of Southern India and India is presently among the top three global producers of many crops, including wheat, rice, pulses, cotton, peanuts, fruits and vegetables. Its gross irrigated crop area of 82.6 million hectares (215.6 million acres) is the largest in the world. India exported $38 billion worth of agricultural products in 2013, making it the seventh largest agricultural exporter worldwide and the sixth largest net exporter. Indian agricultural/horticultural and processed foods are exported to more than 120 countries, primarily in the Middle East, Southeast Asia, SAARC countries, the EU and the United States. India’s food processing industry is one of the largest industries in the country. Agriculture and allied sectors like forestry and fisheries accounted for 13.7% of the GDP (gross domestic product) in 2013, about 50% of the workforce. Though the economic contribution of agriculture to India's GDP is steadily declining with the country's broad-based economic growth, still, agriculture is demographically the broadest economic sector and plays a significant role in the overall socio-economic fabric of India.
Though India produces enough food for herself and exports, the country experiences double irony: there is wide spread hunger and mal-nutrition on the one hand, and on the other- agriculture largely remains non-remunerative. Farmers across the country are demanding for better prices. There have been hundreds of cases of farmer suicides. As a nation we must address the problems of the farmers on a priority basis.
Fake News
Collins Dictionary recently named ‘fake news’ as the word of the year. The UK based lexicographer found that the use of ‘fake news’ registered a 365% rise in the last 12 months. Earlier the committee of the Australian Macquarie Dictionary has proclaimed ‘fake news’ as the word of the year. It refers to deliberate, brazen misinformation with intent to mislead. It is different from ordinary misinformation and disinformation in that it takes the form of real news stories provided by what appear to be legitimate news outlets. It is more dangerous because people tend to easily believe information given to them in the name of news.
Fake news is not a new phenomena. In fact fake news has been around longer than the organized news media itself. Some historians cite ancient Greek writer Herodotus as the founder of selective sourcing; others claiming fake news began in 15th century Italy (where a Franciscan preacher named Bernardino da Feltre used a rumor to justify the mass-arrest, torture, and execution of members of the Italian Jewish community); and still more noting Orson Welles's 1938 radio adaptation of H. G. Wells’s The War of the Worlds, first broadcast as a news bulletin.
Infact, The control, presentation and manipulation of news has played a key role in the assertion and subversion of power in colonial, totalitarian and radical societies throughout history worldwide.
What is happening now is that the manufacturing fake news and disseminating has become easier thanks to development in ICT technology and Internet. Social Media has made it even easier.
As a result, the role of news media as intermediary of news is being increasingly questioned. When the credibility of mainstream news media is questioned, there is a chance of fake news to sneak in. It was difficult to find space in the mindscape of people as mainstream news media used to occupy that. With social media gaining ground fake news has an easy access.
One might question: Why we tend to believe ‘fake news’? Recent and historical work in psychology shows mere exposure to fake news makes it spread. To understand why — and the extent to which false stories seep into our brains, we need to understand the psychology of the illusory truth effect.
The more we hear a piece of information repeated, the more we’re likely to believe it. “Even things that people have reason not to believe, they believe them more” if the claims are repeated, Gord Pennycook, a psychologist who studies the spread of misinformation at Yale University, says.
And recent research shows the illusory truth effect is in play when we hear or read fake news claims repeated, regardless of how ridiculous or illogical they sound
Last year (2016) Oxford Dictionary legitimized an adjective: post truth. It refers to dishonesty and deception in contemporary life, a culture that plays on our emotions and personal belief and drugs us so that perceptions, not facts, determine our actions.
 Taken together it points to a very grim reality. Credibility of news is increasingly suspect.  Media must take proactive steps to engage with this. It is a question of survival of credible media.
Credible media is the mainstay  of informed opinion, which drives democracy. If the foundation is built on a pile of untruth then democracy is doomed.
The real danger lies there.

Tailpiece: Whom to Blame?
Girl (to God): I don’g want to marry. I am educated, independent and self sufficient. I don’t need a husband. But my parents are asking me to marry. What should I do?
God: You are my finest finest creation and undoubtedly will acheve many great things. But some things...inevitable, will not go the way you want. Worse, some things will fail. Whom will you blame? Yourself? No! You need a husband to blame.
Boy (to God)...but then what will I do? Whom will I blame?
God: Your scope is much wider, Son. You can blame the Govt., the education system, the infrastructure, the environment, the economy, the politicians, the bureaucrats...even me. But never ever blame your wife.
***

A journalist turned media academician Mrinal Chatterjee lives in Dhenkanal, a Central Odisha hilly town. He also writes fiction. mrinalchatterjee@ymail.com


Review | Novel: The Tough Gets Going

Review | Dr. Mrinal Chatterjee
The Tough Gets Going (Novel)
Authors: Simanta and Susanta
Publisher: Blue Rose




The Tough Gets Going weaves two genres into a single narrative, the genres being thriller and romance.  The kernel of the plot of the novel lies in a secret which I am not going to reveal to you. I do not want to deny the readers the pleasure of discovering that.
The plot of the novel involves two generations. Among the lead characters are the dotting father and obeying son, two young ladies and assortment of other characters. Interestingly there is no ‘villain’ in the story. Circumstances, happenings that alter the course of one’s life very often play that role.
The narrative moves in a jig jag way jumping from one time frame to the other. This kind of narrative often becomes difficult for the readers to keep track of the story line. However, it is to the credit of the authors that they keep the readers glued. The racy prose does half the work; the lingering secret does the rest.
The Tough Gets Going is the story of Dr. Roshan and his father Sekhar Dev. Roshan idolizes his father Sekhar to the extent that he is ready to sacrifice his budding love for a promise that his father has made. The character of Sekhar is interesting. Passionate about life, Sekhar is an indulging husband and father. However, one momentary lapse pushes him towards tragedy.
The first part of the novel portrays the budding love between Dr. Roshan and Mehak in the unlikeliest of the places: hospital. Mehak is the daughter of a wealthy Muslim businessman  Mr. Khan and his Hindu wife. The opening chapter of the novel narrates a car accident which grieviously injures Mr. Khan and brings him to the hospital. He is treated by Dr. Roshan and there he meets Mehak and falls in love with her. This part has been handled with care and sensitivity, without a trace of wild passion. Roshan is torn between his love for Mehak and his duty to marry Varsha, daughter of his father’s friend and his childhood buddy. It seems the character of Roshan’s friend Dr. Anubhav has been created to etch out the nuances of Roshan's character.
The story moves languidly till Roshan reaches home after completion of his medical education to join a hospital and to marry Varsha. Roshan is in love with Mehak but cannot defy the wishes of his family to marry Varsha. He is almost resigned to his fate.
From here the narrative catches pace, accelerates and moves in break neck speed till the climax. There is a completely unexpected twist in the tale, which makes the novel interesting.
 I enjoyed reading the novel.
I have just two reservations. One – It could have been an excellent short story instead of a 174 pages novel. Novel warrants expanse, which again needs something happening, something meaty. That was lacking in the novel. The canvas is too small. The second reservation is about the interjection of comments and observations in between the narrative which somehow impacted the pace of the novel.
Over all the Tough Gets Going may not be a great literature but it definitely is a good read. 

***
4.11.2017